Promoting Breastfeeding While Being Sensitive to Mothers Who Can’t

By Kaitlin Lewis

Families taking a childbirth class are typically planning to breastfeed after their babies arrive.  I use the anatomy portion on the first night of class to talk about the changing pregnant body.  Part of that discussion is awareness of breast changes throughout the pregnancy.  This is a fine opportunity to encourage people who have not noticed changes to their breast tissue to have a discussion with their health care provider to help them identify if they may be someone who has insufficient glandular tissue.  If they do, they may face extra challenges when breastfeeding their baby. Today, editor Kaitlin Lewis encourages finding the delicate balance between promoting breastfeeding while acknowledging that some people face an uphill battle and may not be able to breastfeed even if they fully intended to. - Sharon Muza, Community Manager, Science & Sensibility.

hypoplasia_tn_5_6_14__64626.1399481288.386.513.jpgBreastfeeding has been identified as a public health concern both nationally and globally. Organizations such as the World Health Organization (WHO, 2003) and the American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP, 2012) have offered policy statements that uphold breastfeeding as the normal and optimal method of infant and young child feeding.

In the United States, the Department of Health and Human Services and Centers for Disease Control and Prevention have specified target rates for breastfeeding initiation, exclusivity, and duration in its Healthy People goals for 2020. While 76.9% of new mothers in the United States initiate breastfeeding, only 43.5% are breastfeeding at all at 6 months. These mothers may be mixed-feeding with breastmilk substitutes or offering solids. At 12 months, only 25.5% of mothers are breastfeeding at all (Center for Disease Control and Prevention [CDC], 2012). These figures are well under the Healthy People 2020 targets of 81.9% of babies initiating breastfeeding, 60.6% of babies still breastfeeding at 6 months, and 34.1% of babies breastfeeding at all at 12 months of age (HHS, Healthy People 2020, 2012).

 In an effort to increase breastfeeding rates, countless organizations and individuals have created and disseminated messages that may be characterized as breastfeeding advocacy, promotion, or support. However, for the mother who cannot produce a full milk supply for her baby, these messages can be hard to hear. She may feel insulted and judged because she was not able to breastfeed exclusively despite her intent and desire to do so.

Exclusive breastfeeding is physiologically impossible for many women with insufficient glandular tissure (IGT), no matter how hard they try or how committed to breastfeeding they might be. This dichotomy between wanting what she has been taught is best for her baby and what she’s actually able to do can be very difficult for a mother with IGT to accept. Messages from well-meaning health care providers—perhaps the same ones that told her throughout her pregnancy that she should consider exclusive breastfeeding—that not breastfeeding “isn’t the end of the world” or “isn’t a big deal” may feel like patronizing lies.

Even worse, the advocacy messages of various breastfeeding promotion campaigns (organized or random) that permeate the “mommy blogosphere” and social media platforms might feel like personal attacks. She wanted to breastfeed, to give her precious baby the very best of everything, and those messages, which practically criminalize artificial infant feeding, do not help her. They might even contribute to the growing sense of anger, guilt, or shame that she’s already experiencing, as this mother describes:

"Being unable to sustain my child, and feeling that my body was broken was devastating for me. No one had ever told me that a failure to produce milk was even possible unless someone “gave up.” I was judged, guilted and made to feel like I was ignorant and lazy by friends, family, and medical professionals and it was not until I found the information buried deep beneath the sea of “all women can breastfeed as long as they try hard enough” that I began to heal."

While the sentiment behind breastfeeding campaigns are meant to stimulate an increase in breastfeeding, it is important to acknowledge that some women cannot bring in a full milk supply. For these women, the campaigns can feel like an attack, adding insult to injury. It is crucial that the creators of these campaigns are aware of this phenomenon and show sensitivity and compassion to mothers who have low to no supply, as not to inadvertently add to their sense of failure or grief.

How do you discuss this topic in your childbirth education or breastfeeding class?  Let's discuss in our comments section below. - SM

Excerpt from Finding Sufficiency: Breastfeeding with Insufficient Glandular Tissue by Diana Cassar-Uhl, MPH, IBCLC.

References

Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. (2014). Breastfeeding Report Card—United States; 2014. h ttp.

Eidelman, A. I., Schanler, R. J., Johnston, M., Landers, S., Noble, L., Szucs, K., & Viehmann, L. (2012). Breastfeeding and the use of human milk.Pediatrics, 129(3), e827-e841.

US Department of Health and Human Services, Office of Disease Prevention and Health Promotion, US Department of Health and Human Services, & Office of Disease Prevention and Health Promotion. (2010). Healthy people 2020.

World Health Organization, & UNICEF. (2003).Global strategy for infant and young child feeding. World Health Organization.

About Kaitlin Lewis

kaitlin lewis headshot 2016.JPGAs a recent graduate with a BA in English, Kaitlin Lewis developed her love of literature and the written word early in life. Editing has always been a passion for Kaitlin and she thoroughly enjoys her work at Praeclarus Press.

 

2 Comments

Thanks for this article!

November 16, 2016 12:42 PM by Kate Lindberg

As a parent with IGT, I so appreciate this article. Thank you for looking at this topic. Words cannot express the heartache and mental health anguish I experienced after birthing my first son due to not producing enough milk. If it wasn't for joining the birth professional community and just happening to see an article posted about Mammary Hypoplasia, to this day I'd still be thinking I am not "doing enough" (despite the 100 million things I have done to try to "fix" it).

This year I had to have a mammogram and as the doctor was looking it over, he commented on how he really loved reading scans "like mine" (ie, basically all fatty tissue) because it is so much easier to distinguish potential problems. I was surprised at how comforting it was to hear him say those words- and not because any breast health problems could possibly be identified easier, but because he had pictures showing my breasts did actually lack what was needed to feed my babies. That's how deep the shame went- that even after knowing and processing for years why I only produce a few mLs a feed, I still felt like I needed hard proof.

There are so many different feelings that come up for me in regards to breastfeeding education. I was told that all women could breastfeed (lactate)- in childbirth class, in books, through campaigns. Even the formula packaging tells you breast milk is best. And of course, I'm not arguing it isn't. I'm just always wondering where the line is to boost breastfeeding in our communities, but also leave room to support those who it doesn't work for, no matter the reason.

Yes, This!

January 22, 2017 07:03 PM by Laura Leingang

I really enjoyed reading this.  My gave birth to my 6th child last November (2015) and he was born with 3 critical heart defects.  As a complication from his open heart surgery, he was unable to breastfeed and it broke my heart, as I had exclusively nursed all of my children long term.  This article helps me to understand how to promote breastfeeding but to also be sensitive to those mothers who for some reason cannot.  I wish that all providers had this information, as I felt that no one was very sensitive to my feelings during this time.

To leave a comment, click on the Comment icon on the left side of the screen.  You must login to submit a comment.  

Recent Stories
Series: Building Your Birth Business - Five Reasons to Consider an Early Pregnancy Class

Causal Inference - A Better Research Method for Studying Labor & Birth?

Two Free Learning Opportunities that Childbirth Educators Will Find Helpful