Food For Thought in Early Labor and Beyond?

By Mindy Cockeram, LCCE

Foods that help during labor.jpgI have always compared labor to mountain climbing. Early labor is when you fuel up, keep warm and plan your route in the safety of your base camp tent. Active labor needs the stamina to traverse icy slopes and overcome unknown weather patterns. Transition is when you teeter over the crevasse on a ladder. Finally, you push, push, push for the summit and once you reach it, what you see renders you relieved, joyous and possibly speechless. Just like when climbing a mountain, food and fluid are the fuels that keep your muscles working and allow you to keep going in labor. Since hospitals generally discourage eating in labor (or outright won’t allow it), we usually have a classroom discussion on useful things to eat at home, in the car and in the parking lot before going in!

Two years ago I listened to a really useful InJoy webinar given by CRNA Amy Wehrman on Oral Intake During Labor which is still available to be viewed at no cost on the Injoy website. (Here is the supporting pdf to go with the webinar.) In the webinar, Amy recommends eating from the BRAT (bananas, rice, applesauce, toast) diet since these foods are gentle on the stomach and less likely to cause vomiting. Of course, she also points out the lack of evidence-based research for denying people food in the hospital but many S&S posts, as well as the recent release of the Lamaze Infographic (No Food, No Drink During Labor? No Way!), have highlighted this - as well as the need for change. Besides the BRAT diet foods, I have come upon a few studies that highlight some food for thought (excuse the pun) in labor.

Baking Soda (SODIUM BICARBONATE)

Athletes employ many different food theories and diets to enhance or improve their performance. One of those methods, referred to as a ‘buffer’, is the use of baking soda (aka sodium bicarbonate). Dissolved in water (0.3g sodium bicarb/kg body weight) and taken roughly an hour before the event allows resistance against muscle exhaustion caused by changes in acid-base balance. Sodium bicarbonate has a proven neutralizing effect on the lactic acid that forms during muscle exertion and improves performance.

In a fascinating study in 2016 out of Sweden and the UK, Wiberg-Itzel, et al, worked together to study the effect of sodium bicarbonate on laboring women whose contractions had become weaker and consequently less effective (dystocic). Two randomized groups of 200 primiparous women in active labor were studied. The first group received no sodium bicarbonate and oxytocin/Pitocin was started immediately (adhering to local clinical guidelines). The second group was each given 4.26g of sodium bicarbonate (using an over the counter aid for indigestion called Samarin which is readily available in Sweden) mixed with 200ml of water an hour before starting oxytocin if no progress in labor was identified.

The results were quite astonishing. 84% of the sodium bicarbonate group went on to have spontaneous deliveries versus 67% of the non-bicarb group. 6.7% of the sodium bicarb group was assisted by vacuum whereas 24.2% of the other group needed vacuum assistance. Newborns from the sodium bicarb group of mothers had overall better outcomes including no APGARS <7. It is quite clear that the sodium bicarb helped the uterus recover from the muscular changes associated with labor exhaustion.

The question remains whether people should consider using sodium bicarb without further studies and if so, how much.   The only known downsides of sodium bicarbonate are that it can contribute to stomach upset and water retention and so some may not tolerate it well. Will people be using a sodium bicarbonate product in early labor routinely in future? Do you have any experience using it?

Yogurt

Over the last few years, the aforementioned BRAT diet has evolved into the BRATY diet with the Y standing for yogurt. One of the reasons I encourage people to eat yogurt during pregnancy is to help avoid Group B Strep colonization. Research by Reid and Burton (2002) concluded that foods that increase lactobacilli in the pregnant person’s diet (i.e. yogurt that contains probiotics like lactobacillus or acidophilus) can happily decrease the chance of GBS infection. In addition, some of the commonly prescribed practices in pregnancy (laxatives for constipation resulting from iron pills and calcium carbonate antacids to reduce heartburn) and the general stress pregnant women experience put them at far higher risk of killing off their ‘good bacteria’.

In labor, any antibiotics received by the pregnant person can kill off their good bacteria. The death of good bacteria also decreases the parent’s immunity and increases the likelihood of food allergies in the baby (Love B, et al, 2016) so eating yogurt both during and after labor can help (re)build good bacteria. Yogurt is a super source of protein and calcium and is usually well tolerated, even in people who are lactose intolerant.

Protein Shake

In 2009, ACOG relaxed their view on fluids during labor to include clear liquids including black coffee, fruit juices without pulp, clear tea, carbonated beverages and sports drinks. What about a protein shake in labor? After all, protein shakes are used by professional athletes to help increase endurance. In 2013, researchers at the University of Pittsburgh evaluated people who drank a 325ml protein shake (Premier Nutrition) within 15 minutes of receiving an epidural. Their hope was that the protein shake would reduce the incidence of nausea, vomiting, and gastric emptying. Sadly the results did not support their theory although the outcomes were statistically insignificant. The lead researcher Manuel Vallejo Jr, MD did, however, state “Physicians should feel comfortable replacing ice chips or water with a high-protein liquid supplement when vaginal delivery is expected.

What the study did highlight, however, was the overall increase in satisfaction from the people allowed the protein shake. Isn’t anything that increases a person’s satisfaction in labor without increasing adverse consequences worth pursuing?

Xylitol-based chewing gum

This last item is one I recommend people have in their hospital bag ‘just in case’. While I hope that the people in my class don’t experience a cesarean section, I’m well aware that the cesarean section rate in our local hospitals - more than half of which are unplanned – mimic the national average at approximately 32%. After a cesarean section, people in our area are not generally released until they have produced a bowel movement. This can be a particularly stressful thought or act at a time when healing is paramount. In a 2017 study in the Journal of Maternal-Fetal Neonatal Medicine, researchers Ciardulli, et al reviewed seventeen randomized control trials (representing over 3000 people) to examine the effect of people using chewing gum after a cesarean section. They concluded that: “Gum chewing starting right after cesarean delivery three times a day for about 30 min (until the first flatus) is associated with early recovery of bowel motility. As this is a simple, generally inexpensive intervention, providers should consider implementing cesarean postoperative care with gum chewing.

Of course, the next question would undoubtedly be what kind of gum? A recent study from Taiwan (Lee, et al, 2016) specifically examined the effect of the natural sweetener Xylitol in gum. The study used three control groups (gum containing Xylitol, Xylitol-free gum or no gum) to determine whether Xylitol-based gum should be recommended. They concluded “After cesarean section, chewing gum increased participants' return of bowel activity, as measured by the appearance of bowel sounds and the passage of flatus. In this context, xylitol-containing gum may be superior to xylitol-free gum.” Not only is Xylitol billed as helping to prevent tooth decay, it prompts the mouth to produce more saliva which in turn would start involuntary peristalsis.

Although the studies I read did not talk about specific guidelines for xylitol dosage, I came across a few brands (Pur, Epic Xylitol, Xlyoburst) which carried roughly one gram per serving (serving = one piece of gum) and could be ordered online or found in health food stores.   Interestingly, one of the warning labels I read mentioned the possible side effects of exceeding 40-50g of xylitol: diarrhea, borborygmi (rumbling sounds of gas moving through the intestine) colic; and increased bowel movements. Of course, these side effects (in moderation) are exactly the reason xylitol based gum can be useful after a cesarean section or any surgery which could impair the intestinal tract.

Food for thought?

Would you feel comfortable sharing the science behind ingesting baking soda and yogurt in labor? How about a protein shake? Would it be useful to discuss xylitol chewing gum for faster recovery of bowel motility following a cesarean section? What do you recommend that people eat in labor? Have you found any foods or fluids that worked well for you or the families you educate?

References:

Ciardulli, Saccone G, Di Mascio D, Caissutti C, Berghella. Chewing gum improves postoperative recovery of gastrointestinal function after cesarean delivery: a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized trials. J Matern Fetal Neonatal Med. 2018; 31(14):1924-1932.

Jian Tao Lee, RN, PhD, Mei-Hui Hsieh, MS, Po-Jen Cheng, MD, and Jr-Rung Lin, PhD. The Role of Xylitol Gum Chewing in Restoring Postoperative Bowel Activity After Cesarean Section. Biological Research For Nursing. 2015; Vol 18, Issue 2, pp. 167 - 172

Love BL, Mann JR, Hardin JW, Lu ZK, Cox C, Amrol DJ. Antibiotic prescription and food allergy in young children. Allergy, Asthma, and Clinical Immunology : Official Journal of the Canadian Society of Allergy and Clinical Immunology. 2016;12:41. doi:10.1186/s13223-016-0148-7.

Oral intake during labor. ACOG Committee Opinion No. 441. American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists. Obstet Gynecol 2009;114:714.

Vallejo Jr M. American Society of Anesthesiologists (ASA) 2013 Annual Meeting. Abstract #1066. Presented October 12, 2013.

Wiberg-Itzel E, Wray S, Akerud H. A randomized controlled trial of a new treatment for labor dystocia. The Journal of Maternal-Fetal & Neonatal Medicine. DOI: 10.1080/14767058.2017.133268.

About Mindy Cockeram, LCCE

mindy cockeram head shot 2016.pngMindy Cockeram is a Certified Lamaze Childbirth Educator working with a large hospital chain in Southern California where she’s been teaching for six years. She trained initially through the UK’s National Childbirth Trust in Wimbledon, England in 2006 after a career in the financial markets industry in London. She graduated from Villanova University in 1986 with a bachelor’s degree in Communications and a minor in Business Studies. Mindy is the author of "Cut Your Labor in Half: 19 Secrets to a Faster and Easier Birth".  She resides in Redlands, California with her British husband and two children.

 

4 Comments
1 Like

Food for Thought

May 26, 2018 07:08 AM by Linda J. Middlekauff, RN, BSN, LCCE

Thank you for this interesting article!  I've been recommending the use of yogurt or probiotics to help prevent or reverse GBS infection (See Evidence Based Birth GBS article).  My students also learn about using the BRAT diet in early labor & into active labor, and they know to listen to their bodies, etc.

I searched for and found the abstracts from the ASA October 2013 meeting but could not find the Vallejo study which recommended the use of protein shakes in labor.  While it seems logical, and the international studies you described show some benefit, I'd like to actually see the studies.

Re: the use of sodium bicarb, various sports drinks contain electrolytes (check w provider for those with heart problems & diabetics should use the sugar free varieties + check w provider).  Smart Water is a good source of electrolytes as well (contains 10 mg Calcium, 10 mg Magnesium, & 10 mg Potassium/Liter).  I was wondering if these were considered as sources for sodium?

Another concern I have is about the use of xylitol post-operatively for Cesarean moms.   I noticed that one group in the study cited chewed gum without xylitol, and their bowels were also stimulated due to the activation of the salivary glands and swallowing (my assumption).  Why not just promote the use of non-medicated gum, walking, fiber, etc.?

Currently, the American Dental Society is encouraging the use of xylitol gum for expectant moms and is providing grants to my community's health organizations and providers to do so.

My concern is that the xylitol not only stimulates the intestines (which is a good thing post-op), but it also destroys the normal flora in the mouth of the mother.  We already know that babies born via Cesarean have a different gut microbiota than those born vaginally, one that is less effective in assisting the immune system develop the ability to protect the baby against things like eczema, asthma, etc. The use of this gum could inadvertently affect the microbiota of the mother's gut, and the use of her vaginal/rectal secretions which some recommend be used to wipe onto the newborn's nose, mouth & skin may become ineffective.

 

Food for Thought

May 26, 2018 07:13 AM by Linda J. Middlekauff, RN, BSN, LCCE

Correction to my first comment:  While I realize that Smart Water does not contain sodium, Gatorade does (contains 45 mg potassium & 150 mg sodium).  

 

What the American society of Anesthesiologists admits

May 26, 2018 08:09 AM by Jacqueline Levine, LCCE,FACCE,CD, CLC

In 2015 in San Diego, research presented at the ANESTHESIOLOGY® 2015 annual meeting suggested that most healthy women can skip the fasting and, in fact, would benefit from eating a light meal during labor. Improvements in anesthesia care have made pain control during labor safer, reducing risks related to eating, researchers note.“Our findings suggest a change in practice makes sense,” said Christopher Harty, BN, co-author of the study.  Ok, so one wonders why it's still necessary for hospitals to avoid best-evidence care for patients and "not allow" food or drink?  But thank you for such a nicely written article on a vital and interesting subject.  Now let's get rid of routine IV, and save it for compelling medical reasons...

 

Food for thought

June 2, 2018 07:19 AM by Mindy A. Cockeram, LCCE

Hi Linda,

I don't know anything about the use of xylitol based gum pre-labor.  I'd be interested in the connection between a mom chewing xylitol based gum in pregnancy, the association with any changes in her gut/bodily flora and the babys'.   And you are right - chewing gum to get the bowels moving doesn't necessarily have to be xylitol based - it's just the study intimated that xylitol's side effects made motility more efficient faster.

Seems that Gatorade (bearing in mind what you say about sugars, etc) would be a super alternative to straight sodium bicarb - esp with the other ingredients - to drink in early labor.

Glad you enjoyed the article!

 

To leave a comment, click on the Comment icon on the left side of the screen.  You must login to submit a comment.  

Recent Stories
Birth & Parenting Classes Geared for Fathers are Well Received

Research Review: A Prenatal Blood Test that Accurately Determines Gestational Age and Prematurity Risk?

Lamaze International Wishes Penny Simkin a Happy 80th & Congratulations on 50 Years of Teaching Birth Classes